The 11 Best Restaurants Amelia Island

Amelia Island, a hidden gem in Florida, offers pristine beaches, historical sites, and a vibrant culinary scene that delights food enthusiasts. Whether you’re craving freshly caught seafood, classic Southern comfort food, or innovative cuisine that fuses diverse flavors, the best restaurants in Amelia Island offer an unforgettable dining experience. Join us as we explore the top dining destinations that embody the island’s charming character and serve up dishes sure to create lasting memories. Discover where ambiance meets flavor and where every meal becomes a cherished moment on this enchanting island.

Brief overview of Amelia Island as a destination for food lovers

Amelia Island emerges as a paradise for food lovers, offering an eclectic mix of eateries that are as rich in flavors as the island’s history is in tales. Renowned for its locally sourced seafood and commitment to farm-to-table freshness, this culinary haven provides an adventure in every bite. The island’s eateries range from quaint bistros tucked away under the oaks to elegant fine dining establishments overlooking the Atlantic waves.

Add to this the annual food festivals celebrating everything from shrimp to the island’s unique multicultural heritage, and it’s clear that Amelia Island is a true gastronomic delight for epicureans seeking authenticity and innovation on their plates.

Factors Considered for Selecting the Best Restaurants

In curating our list of Amelia Island’s best dining spots, several vital factors were meticulously examined to ensure that only the finest restaurants were cut. Quality of Ingredients is paramount; the use of fresh, local, and high-caliber products stands as a fundamental criterion. 

Culinary Creativity is also critical, as exceptional establishments distinguish themselves through innovative menus and inspired flavor combinations. We also consider the Ambience and location of the restaurant, as the setting contributes significantly to the overall dining experience. Not to be overlooked, the Service Excellence provided by the staff highlights the hospitality that enhances every meal.

Lastly, Diner Reviews and Critic Ratings play an influential role; the voices of both locals and visitors alike are integral in identifying those eateries that consistently impress and leave a lasting impression.

11 Best Restaurants Amelia Island

Restaurant 1: Burlingame Restaurant

Description of the restaurant

Nestled in the heart of Amelia Island, Burlingame Restaurant presents a refined dining experience in a cozy yet upscale setting. With an emphasis on casual elegance, the restaurant’s inviting atmosphere is perfect for both intimate dinners and special occasions.

The dedicated team at Burlingame is committed to offering impeccable service, ensuring that each guest’s experience is as delightful as the cuisine. Attention to detail shines through in every aspect, from the artfully plated dishes to the carefully curated wine list, making Burlingame a standout dining destination on the island.

Highlighted dishes and specialties

Burlingame Restaurant shines with its seasonally inspired menu that showcases the best of local produce and seafood. A perennial favorite is the pan-eared scallops, expertly prepared with a citrusy beurre blanc that complements the sweetness of the scallops. Meat lovers will savor the Herb-Crusted Rack of Lamb, served with a side of rich, truffled mashed potatoes.

Not to miss is the Burlingame Beet Salad, a harmonious blend of roasted beets, goat cheese, and pistachios, all brought together with a tangy orange vinaigrette. Dessert is a must at Burlingame, particularly the decadent Flourless Chocolate Torte that provides the perfect endnote to a memorable meal.

Restaurant 2: David’s

Description of the restaurant

David’s Restaurant & Lounge invites guests to bask in a sumptuous fine dining experience that captures the essence of Amelia Island’s upscale gastronomic charm. The establishment prides itself on a luxurious yet welcoming ambiance, combining modern sophistication with warm, personable service.

David exudes a passion for culinary excellence, delivering an array of dishes that are as visually arresting as they are palate-pleasing. With a focus on prime steaks, fresh seafood, and a hand-selected wine list, David’s sets the stage for an evening of indulgence and culinary discovery.

Highlighted dishes and specialties

David’s is celebrated for its prime cuts, especially the Filet Mignon, which is expertly aged and cooked to buttery perfection. Seafood lovers are drawn to the Chilean Sea Bass, elegantly served with a lobster risotto that elevates the dish to new heights. The Escargot appetizer is another standout, bathed in garlic butter and presented in a way that pays homage to classic French cuisine with a coastal twist.

For dessert, the Crème Brûlée is a must, boasting a perfectly caramelized top and a creamy, rich vanilla bean custard beneath. Each dish at David’s not only satisfies the appetite but also leaves a lasting impression of culinary artistry.

Restaurant 3: España Restaurant and Tapas

Description of the restaurant

España Restaurant and Tapas transports diners to the heart of Spanish cuisine with its charming and vibrant atmosphere reminiscent of a traditional Iberian eatery. Nestled on a quiet street, the restaurant’s outdoor Patio is draped in twinkling lights, offering a romantic setting. At the same time, the interior envelops guests in warm terracotta hues and the lively spirit of Spain.

The family-owned gem is known for its friendly staff and attention to authentic details, inviting guests to indulge in a culinary journey that celebrates the rich flavors and festive dining culture of Spain.

Highlighted dishes and specialties

At España Restaurant and Tapas, the menu is a tapestry of vibrant flavors, where every dish tells a story of Spanish culinary heritage. The Tapas Mixtas platter, featuring an assortment of Spanish meats, cheeses, and olives, is ideal for sharing. The signature Paella Valenciana is a must-try, brimming with saffron-infused rice, seafood, chicken, and chorizo—a flavorful reflection of Spain’s coastal tradition.

Vegetarian visitors will delight in the Pimientos del Piquillo Rellenos, stuffed with a rich blend of herbs and goat cheese. For a sweet finish, the homemade Flan de Caramelo, with its silky texture and deep caramel sauce, offers a classic and satisfying end to the dining experience.

Restaurant 4: The Patio at 5th and Ash

Description of the restaurant

The Patio at 5th and Ash offers a culinary escapade unique to its urban setting, blending the serenity of outdoor dining with the vibrant energy of the city streets. Tucked away in a bustling downtown, this hidden oasis features a quaint, garden-like setting where diners can unwind under the string lights that cast a soft glow after sunset.

The restaurant’s commitment to local sourcing is evident in every dish, and the ambiance strikes the perfect balance between sophistication and a relaxed, inviting atmosphere. It’s an ideal spot for those seeking both an escape from the city rush and a top-tier dining experience.

Highlighted dishes and specialties

At The Patio at 5th and Ash, the Grilled Peach Salad garnished with local arugula, candied walnuts, and creamy burrata is a celebration of seasonal flavors. The Braised Short Ribs are another standout, slow-cooked to fall-off-the-bone tenderness and served alongside garlic-infused mashed potatoes.

Seafood enthusiasts will be drawn to the Lemon Herb Grilled Salmon, perfectly paired with a crisp fennel salad. For those with a sweet tooth, the Salted Caramel Pot de Crème provides a perfect blend of savory sweetness to round off the dining experience, establishing The Patio as a destination for both its ambiance and its cuisine.

Restaurant 5: Café Karibo

Description of the restaurant

Café Karibo is a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the historic district, distinguished by its casual and eclectic charm. The café boasts a colorful and artsy interior along with a tranquil outdoor patio embraced by lush greenery, offering a picturesque dining experience.

It has built a reputation on its laid-back ambiance, friendly service, and a menu that caters to diverse tastes and dietary preferences. Café Karibo is a delightful retreat where friends and family can come together over good food in a relaxed environment that feels like a home away from home.

Highlighted dishes and specialties

At Café Karibo, patrons relish a selection of dishes that are both comforting and imaginative. The Turkey Avocado Wrap is a crowd-pleaser, combining fresh ingredients in a hearty, healthful package. The Vegetarian Hummus Plate beckons with its house-made hummus, crisp vegetables, and warm pita, ideal for a light but fulfilling meal.

The Shrimp and Grits offer a Southern-inspired indulgence, blending the zest of Cajun spices with the creamy texture of stone-ground grits. Don’t skip dessert – the Key Lime Pie, characterized by its tangy filling and buttery crust, is a tribute to Florida’s favorite flavors.

Restaurant 6: Beech Street Grill

Description of the restaurant

Beech Street Grill, set in a beautifully restored Victorian mansion, exudes a charm that transcends time. With its ornate woodwork and expansive porches, the restaurant offers a dining experience wrapped in nostalgia and elegance.

The ambiance is one of refined comfort, inviting guests to savor their meals amidst a backdrop of historical sophistication. Known for its impeccable service and an atmosphere that whispers tales of the past, Beech Street Grill is the perfect destination for those who appreciate a side of history with their exquisite cuisine.

Highlighted dishes and specialties

The culinary offerings at Beech Street Grill are a homage to both classic and contemporary tastes. The Prime Rib is a house favorite, known for its juicy richness and served with a side of creamy horseradish sauce. The pan-shaped scallops accented with a lemon-butter sauce are a testament to the Grill’s expertise in seafood.

A must-try is the Roasted Beet Salad, a vibrant dish with goat cheese, walnuts, and a drizzle of balsamic reduction. For dessert, the Chocolate Torte with raspberry coulis is an indulgence worthy of the setting, providing a sweet endnote to a memorable dining experience.

Restaurant 7: First Love Brewing 

Description of the restaurant

First Love Brewing is a testament to passion-driven craftsmanship, where the art of brewing meets culinary ingenuity in a laid-back, contemporary space. This Brewery pulls double duty as a community hub, inviting beer lovers and foodies alike to savor artisanal brews and elevated pub fare.

The interior boasts an industrial-chic ambiance with an open-concept brewery visible to guests, adding an educational twist to every visit. First Love Brewing’s commitment to locally sourced ingredients and innovative flavors makes it a standout destination for a casual evening out or a celebratory gathering.

Highlighted dishes and specialties

The menu at First Love Brewing is thoughtfully curated to complement the in-house craft beer selection. Specialties include the Brewer’s Pretzel, an oversized, soft-baked pretzel served with a robust beer cheese dip. The IPA-Battered Fish and Chips showcase a perfect blend of crunch and ale-infused flavor.

For a heartier option, the Brewmaster’s Burger is a hit, topped with house-made beer cheese, caramelized onions, and a signature sauce. Beer enthusiasts will want to try the seasonal Hop-Infused Wings, with a sauce selection inspired by their latest brews. Ending on a high note, the Stout Chocolate Brownie offers a decadent, malty dessert that echoes the depth of their stout beer.

Restaurant 8: The Boat House

Description of the restaurant

The Boat House stands as a serene sanctuary by the water, melding panoramic views with a menu that mirrors the freshness of the sea. Its nautical-themed decor and floor-to-ceiling windows allow diners to watch boats lazily drift by as they enjoy their meal. The restaurant’s commitment to using locally sourced seafood and employing sustainable practices is evident in the quality of its offerings.

A favorite among locals and visitors alike, The Boat House is a culinary anchor for those seeking a memorable seaside dining experience where the ocean’s bounty is celebrated with every plate.

Highlighted dishes and specialties

The Oysters on the Half Shell, fresh from the local beds and served with a zesty mignonette, is a pure start to the gastronomic voyage at The Boat House. For mains, the Seared Sea Scallops with a lemon beurre blanc is a symphony of flavors, while the Whole Grilled Snapper embodies the simplicity of seaside fare.

Land lovers are not forgotten, with the Herb-Crusted Rack of Lamb providing a succulent alternative. Finally, to conclude the nautical journey, the Key West Lime Tart seduces the palate with its sweet yet tart flavor profile, reminiscent of the nearby tropical paradises.

Restaurant 9: Wicked Bao 

Description of the restaurant

Wicked Bao is the cornerstone of flavor in downtown Fernandina, where the vibrant essence of Asian street food is brought to life. The restaurant features a fusion of traditional and contemporary design, with bold colors and lanterns that set an upbeat and inviting atmosphere. Guests are greeted with the tantalizing aromas of spices and the sizzling sounds of works from the open kitchen.

It is a place not just for a meal but for an experience that excites the senses and ignites a love for Asian cuisine. The informal, lively setting makes Wicked Bao an ideal spot for a quick bite or a social dining escapade.

Highlighted dishes and specialties

At Wicked Bao, the flavors are as bold as the atmosphere, with a menu that highlights the best of Asian street food. The Pork Belly Bao, with its tender meat and punchy pickle wrapped in a soft, steamed bun, is a must-try. The Lemongrass Chicken Banh Mi combines vibrant herbs and pickled vegetables in a crusty baguette.

Traditionalists will delight in the Pho, a fragrant beef broth noodle soup that soothes with every spoonful. For those with adventurous palates, the Kimchi Fries surprise with a fusion of Korean and Western flavors. The sweet touch to finish is the Mango Sticky Rice, a dessert that weaves the subtle sweetness of ripe mango with the richness of coconut cream.

Restaurant 10: Amelia Island Brewing Co.  

Description of the restaurant

Amelia Island Brewing Co. is a cherished retreat for those who revel in the union of craft brews and inventive food pairings. Encased within a rustic yet modern framework, this local haunt prides itself on a welcoming atmosphere that appeals to both residents and tourists.

With an array of handcrafted beers served alongside a menu of locally inspired dishes, Amelia Island Brewing Co. is a celebration of community and the artistry of brewing. Its relaxed patio area and cozy indoor seating provide the perfect backdrop for a laid-back meal with friends or a leisurely beer-tasting session.

Highlighted dishes and specialties

The Brewery takes pride in its selection of inspired dishes that perfectly complement its range of beers. The Ale-Infused Brisket Slider is a fan favorite, incorporating slow-cooked brisket with a tangy ale barbecue sauce. The Brewery Nachos are piled high, featuring house-made beer cheese and an assortment of fresh toppings. Seafood lovers can revel in the Beer-Battered Shrimp, using the Brewery’s signature ale for the batter.

Vegetarians aren’t left behind with the Harvest Flatbread, adorned with seasonal vegetables and a balsamic glaze. To complete the experience, indulge in the Beer Infused Ice Cream for a truly unique dessert that captures the essence of local brews.

Restaurant 11: The Addison on Amelia Island

Description of the restaurant

The Addison on Amelia Island exudes a historic charm that transports diners to a bygone era. Nestled in the heart of the island, this beloved establishment is housed in a beautifully restored Victorian mansion, surrounded by picturesque gardens and sprawling live oaks.

The elegant dining rooms and tranquil outdoor seating provide an intimate setting for an unforgettable culinary journey. Renowned for its impeccable service and refined ambiance, The Addison is a treasure amid the island’s dining scene, perfect for special occasions or a romantic evening out.

Highlighted dishes and specialties

Culinary excellence is the cornerstone of The Addison, with each dish artfully presented and crafted from the freshest local ingredients. The menu changes seasonally, but guests can always expect to be delighted by creations such as the Amelia Island Shrimp and Grits, where succulent shrimp are paired with creamy, stone-ground grits.

The Duck Confit with Cherry Gastrique offers a balance of rich flavors with a sweet and tangy reduction. Vegetarians will be enchanted by the Garden Risotto, bursting with the colors and flavors of local produce. For dessert, the Vanilla Bean Crème Brûlée is a study in simplicity, its crisp caramelized top giving way to a velvety custard that is the definition of indulgence.

Unique Selling Points of Each Restaurant

Burlingame Restaurant 

Known for its exceptional farm-to-table cuisine, Burlingame Restaurant is a haven for foodies seeking mindful dining. Our dedication lies in utilizing locally sourced, seasonal ingredients to craft a vibrant and ever-evolving menu. At the same time, the serene Ambience of the dining space provides an ideal setting for a sophisticated gastronomic experience.

David’s 

David’s is celebrated for its sumptuous steak and seafood offerings and its opulent dining environment that echoes delicate dining elegance. With a wine list as impressive as the premium cuts it serves, David’s stands out as a destination for those who cherish the finer aspects of dining and life.

España Restaurant and Tapas 

España Restaurant and Tapas brings the vibrant flavors of Spain to Amelia Island with authentic tapas and paellas. The restaurant’s cozy atmosphere, complete with a romantic outdoor garden, makes it an excellent choice for guests looking to indulge in a slice of Spanish culture.

The Patio at 5th and Ash 

The Patio at 5th and Ash offers a casual, al fresco dining experience in a lively, garden-like setting. Perfect for a relaxing meal with friends and family, this eatery’s charm lies in its combination of a friendly atmosphere, live music, and a menu that focuses on fresh, artisanal fare.

Café Karibo 

Café Karibo stands out for its eclectic menu and the adjacent Karibrew Pub, where diners can enjoy a range of house-made beers. The café’s quirky, artsy vibe, coupled with a spacious patio shaded by ancient oaks, makes it a unique spot for a laid-back brunch or a casual dinner with live entertainment.

Beech Street Grill 

The Beech Street Grill is known for its iconic setting in a historic, Queen Anne-style home, offering guests a nostalgic dining experience. The Grill’s menu boasts classic American fare with a sophisticated twist. It emphasizes the use of local seafood, which can be enjoyed on the grand wraparound porch for a charming Southern dining affair.

First Love Brewing 

First Love Brewing captivates beer enthusiasts and foodies alike with its selection of exceptional craft beers brewed on-site and a complementary menu featuring gourmet pub fare. The brewpub’s community-oriented spirit and family-friendly environment, together with its innovative beer-infused recipes, make it a standout locale for casual gatherings.

The Boat House 

The Boat House presents an unbeatable waterfront dining experience, allowing guests to enjoy the freshest seafood amidst panoramic views of the marina. Its commitment to serving ocean-to-table dishes, such as its signature catch of the day, elevates the dining experience, ensuring a memorable outing for seafood lovers.

Wicked Bao 

Wicked Bao offers a bold and authentic taste of Asian street food, with a menu that perfectly captures the essence of flavors from the East. The vibrant atmosphere of the restaurant, combined with its modern interpretation of traditional bao buns and other Asian delicacies, makes it a hotspot for adventurous diners.

Amelia Island Brewing Co. 

Positioned as a hub for craft beer enthusiasts, Amelia Island Brewing Co. not only provides a diverse array of meticulously brewed beers but also a vibrant atmosphere that celebrates local culture. Their dedication to pairing hearty, beer-friendly cuisine with their house brews creates a profoundly satisfying gastronomic experience for visitors.

The Addison on Amelia Island 

Set apart by its historical allure, The Addison on Amelia Island offers a dining experience steeped in Southern elegance and charm. Its ever-evolving menu showcases the finest local ingredients. At the same time, the setting, enveloped by the tranquility of lush gardens and a picturesque Victorian mansion, promises an enchanting escape from the ordinary.

Customer Reviews and Ratings

The eateries of Amelia Island are more than just dining establishments; they are vital parts of the community experienced through the voices of their patrons. Customer reviews and ratings reflect the memorable encounters that locals and travelers alike cherish.

Visitors often rave about the unparalleled service, the ambiance that captures the essence of the island’s charm, and the innovative cuisine that leaves a lasting impression on the palate. Positive testimonials frequently highlight the welcoming staff at Café Karibo, the romantic settings at España Restaurant and Tapas, and the farm-fresh ingredients featured at Burlingame Restaurant.

Moreover, the standout performances by The Addison in delivering a luxurious Southern dining experience have earned it high praise and numerous five-star ratings. Each review is a testament to the dedication these restaurants have to excellence, making Amelia Island not just a destination but a gastronomic journey worth taking.

Conclusion

Amelia Island is a culinary treasure trove, boasting an array of dining establishments that cater to every palate. From the farm-fresh sophistication at Burlingame Restaurant to David’s steak and seafood mastery and the authentic Spanish experience at España Restaurant and Tapas, each venue brings its unique flair. The relaxed settings of The Patio at 5th and Ash and Café Karibo, along with the historic charm of Beech Street Grill, offer diverse atmospheres for savoring a meal.

Craft beer enthusiasts find a sanctuary at both First Love Brewing and Amelia Island Brewing Co. At the same time, waterfront views at The Boat House and the Asian culinary adventures at Wicked Bao offer distinctive dining experiences.

Lastly, the Southern elegance of The Addison on Amelia Island completes this list of top-notch eateries. We encourage you to embark on a gastronomic journey across Amelia Island to explore these culinary delights, each promising an unforgettable dining adventure that genuinely captures the spirit and taste of this enchanting locale.

Frequently Asked and Questions

What are the best dining options for vegetarians on Amelia Island?

Vegetarian diners will find a welcoming array of options, particularly at Café Karibo, which offers an eclectic menu with numerous plant-based dishes. Wicked Bao also provides vegetarian-friendly choices, focusing on the rich and diverse flavors of Asian cuisine.

Do any Amelia Island restaurants offer live entertainment?

Yes, many establishments, such as The Patio at 5th and Ash and Café Karibo, regularly feature live music, adding to the vibrant and enjoyable dining atmosphere.

Can I find any waterfront dining experiences on Amelia Island?

The Boat House stands out as the premier location for waterfront dining, where guests can savor ocean-to-table seafood offerings with stunning views of the marina.

Are there family-friendly dining options on the island?

First Love Brewing prides itself on its community-oriented spirit and family-friendly setting, making it an excellent choice for diners of all ages.

How can I find dining options that focus on locally sourced ingredients?

The Addison on Amelia Island is known for showcasing local ingredients in its gourmet dishes. Beech Street Grill also emphasizes the use of local seafood in its American cuisine.

Is there a place for craft beer lovers?

Craft beer lovers will appreciate the selection at Amelia Island Brewing Co. and the house-made brews at the adjacent Karibrew Pub near Café Karibo.

For more information or to answer any further inquiries, please feel free to contact the individual establishments directly. Each restaurant’s commitment to quality and customer satisfaction ensures that your dining experience on Amelia Island will be a memorable one.